Connect with us

Anglais

Ontario seeks to cut pay for family doctors, but MDs dispute claim they make too much for too little work

admin

Published

on


The provincial government wants to claw back how much it pays thousands of Ontario family doctors and force them to put in longer hours, arguing they are averaging $400,000-plus annually for what amounts to part-time work.

Doctors are up in arms over the proposals and charge that the government has got it wrong when it comes to their workload. They warn if they are hit with another pay cut — on top of one imposed four years ago as well as an ongoing compensation freeze — patients will pay the price because family physicians will be driven from the field.

Dr. Tara Kiran, vice chair of quality and innovation in the Department of Family and Community Medicine at the University of Toronto, said she worries deep cuts being proposed by the province will make if difficult for patients to find family doctors.
Dr. Tara Kiran, vice chair of quality and innovation in the Department of Family and Community Medicine at the University of Toronto, said she worries deep cuts being proposed by the province will make if difficult for patients to find family doctors.  (Rene Johnston / Toronto Star)

“I’m worried that the deep cuts being proposed will make it near impossible for people to find a family doctor, and that will have repercussions for the whole health system,” family doctor Tara Kiran, vice chair of quality and innovation in the Department of Family and Community Medicine at the University of Toronto, wrote in an email.

The two sides have been arguing their cases before a board of arbitration, which completed seven months of hearings Sunday. The Ontario Medical Association contends the government has built its case upon faulty findings by the provincial auditor.

The arbitration board is tasked with resolving an almost-five-year-old contract dispute between the government and the OMA, which represents the province’s 31,000 practising physicians.

Read more:

Province eyeing creation of ‘super health agency,’ sources say

Schism within government on how to deal with the Ontario Medical Association puts premier and health minister at odds

MDs question motives, results of vote by specialists trying to break away from OMA

The government’s proposed changes to family medicine (also known as primary care) are among the most controversial issues the board has been asked to weigh in on as part of its deliberations over the size of the physician services budget. Ontario now spends more than $12 billion — or 10 per cent of the entire provincial budget — on doctors.

The three-member board is expected to come down with binding decisions this spring, ending phase 1 of the arbitration process.

Phase 2, expected to be even more contentious, will address how to divvy up the pot of money among some 35 specialty groups.

All of this is happening at the same time the province is undertaking a massive restructuring of the entire health system. Next week, the government is expected to announce the creation of a new “super health agency” to replace more than 20 smaller agencies. Sources say the super agency will oversee primary care.

The 5,300-plus family doctors facing the prospect of pay cuts comprise about half of Ontario’s roughly 11,000 practising primary care doctors. They work in more than 800 group practices across the province, known as “family health organizations,” or FHOs.

FHOs were developed in 2007 to improve primary care — for example, by increasing access through after-hours availability — largely through changing financial incentives for doctors.

Twelve years later, the government argues it has paid for improvements in care, which have not materialized and that the price is too high to expand this model further.

In the past, family doctors were paid mostly through fee-for-service, which saw them reimbursed for every service rendered. There is an inherent incentive in the fee-for-service model to have high-volume practices; the more services provided, the more money made.

But under FHOs, doctors derive the bulk of their income through “capitation,” a form of compensation that reimburses them a set amount for each patient signed up with them — no matter how many times a patient is seen or even if a patient is not seen. The amount varies according to a patient’s age and health.

Three-person board of arbitration tasked with resolving OMA contract dispute: Ron Pink, OMA nominee, left, Bill Kaplan, board chair, centre, and Kevin Smith, health ministry nominee.
Three-person board of arbitration tasked with resolving OMA contract dispute: Ron Pink, OMA nominee, left, Bill Kaplan, board chair, centre, and Kevin Smith, health ministry nominee.  (Rene Johnston/Toronto Star)

In 2016/17, the average FHO doctor (with 1,300 patients) made $406,390, according to the government’s written submission to the arbitration panel. That compares to $214,015 for a family doctor paid fee-for-service.

(Physician compensation is not the same as income. From their compensation, FHO doctors have to pay for overhead costs such as staff salaries and rent. Arrangements vary from practice to practice, with the health ministry, hospitals and local communities also pitching in for non-physician expenses.)

Some fee-for-service family doctors and specialists have even taken to social media to argue that their FHO peers are paid too much.

The government’s submission states that FHOs have become so popular, the number of doctors working in them has surged by 154 per cent since 2008/09. To contain costs, the ministry says it was forced to limit their growth starting in 2012.

The government is now seeking to cut the pay of FHO doctors by an average of 9 per cent each, or about $33,600. That would be on top of a cut of 2.65 per cent the province imposed in 2015, as well as a compensation freeze in place since 2012.

In making its case, the government relies heavily on the 2016 provincial auditor’s report, which states that FHOs have not proven their worth. FHO doctors were paid $522 million more in 2014/15 than they would have received if they were paid fee-for-service, according to the report.

That was, in part, because they were paid for 1.8 million patients rostered with them, even though they did not actually see those patients, the auditor wrote.

“The $522 million is significant, as it indicates that the physicians were not providing core primary care services as often as they should be (or expected to be) and/or that base capitation payments are excessive,” the report reads.

The auditor found that an average FHO doctor works only 3.4 days per week.

The province made significant investments in FHOs, but “most objectives (were) not met,” wrote the auditor, charging that they failed to increase access to care, quality and continuity of care and cost effectiveness.

FHOs have not delivered on commitments to provide after-hours care, the auditor said, adding they have also not done much to shorten wait times for primary care.

Many patients get their primary care elsewhere, including walk-in clinics, other family doctors and hospital emergency departments, meaning the province is paying twice for these patients to be treated, according to the report.

The auditor concluded by urging the province to review how much it pays these doctors to ensure taxpayers are getting good value for money.

In addition to seeking pay cuts, the province wants more work and accountability from FHO doctors. The government wants the average physician to put in a 36-hour work week.

“It’s a very expensive model to deliver primary care physician services and it is not performing optimally,” government negotiating team member Bob Bass told the arbitration board on a recent hearing day. “From the government’s perspective, significant change is required to both moderate the costs and improve the quality.”

But the OMA says the government has built its case on bad information from the auditor who failed to understand how they work.

OMA lawyer Howard Goldblatt said the government is more intent on prescribing or dictating a solution without really diagnosing the problem.
OMA lawyer Howard Goldblatt said the government is more intent on prescribing or dictating a solution without really diagnosing the problem.  (Supplied photo)

“It was done by accountants, not by doctors,” OMA lawyer Howard Goldblatt told the arbitration panel, referring to the auditor’s report.

“The government is more intent on prescribing or dictating a solution without really diagnosing the problem,” he continued.

The OMA wants the government to join it in studying FHOs so that any decisions taken are based on what it contends is accurate information.

The auditor erred by calculating the workload of FHO doctors based on the number of patient visits, the OMA charges.

It stands to reason many patients would have fewer appointments, given one reason for creating FHOs was to move doctors away from high-volume, fee-for-service practices, the OMA argues. Financial incentives were changed to encourage doctors to deal with multiple conditions in a single visit rather than call patients back for multiple visits.

(Depending on the doctor, those working in fee-for-service family practices may also deal with multiple conditions in a single visit.)

The auditor also failed to take into account the fact FHO doctors are more likely to communicate with patients via email and phone since their pay is no longer based on face-to-face visits, the OMA adds.

Then there is all the paperwork that comes with working in a FHO, noted Kiran who practices out of one in downtown Toronto. Because FHOs provide full-service family medicine, there is much administrative work associated with appointments, tests and referrals, she explained, adding that FHO doctors also spend time communicating with other providers in a patient’s circle of care.

“This work is what can lead to burnout and frustration, and is not accounted for in the government’s proposals,” she wrote in her email.

Kiran and the OMA warn the proposed changes to family medicine will drive doctors back to practising high-volume, fee-for-service medicine.

“Family doctors would be forced to see a ludicrously high volume of patients in-person each day,” she said. “For patients, this would likely mean shorter appointments, less flexibility to bring up multiple problems in a single visit, and less flexibility to call or email your doctor about an issue.”

The OMA points out another reason for introducing FHOs was to address past shortages of family doctors by making family medicine more attractive. The proposed changes threaten to turn back the clock on those gains, doctors argue.

In a written brief submitted to the arbitration panel, the OMA used strong language to warn of dire consequences if the arbitrators and government get it wrong:

The ministry’s proposals have “the potential to cause huge destabilization in primary care … The very real risk to patient quality of care and provider well-being cannot be ignored.”

Theresa Boyle is a Toronto-based reporter covering health. Follow her on Twitter: @theresaboyle



Source link

قالب وردپرس

Anglais

A stunning Water Lantern Festival is coming to Montreal

admin

Published

on

By

What might just be the most magical night ever is coming up for Montreal this year.

The Water Lantern Festival has announced that it will be gracing Mississauga with thousands of floating lanterns later this year, as part of a celebration that spans the entire world.

According to the festival’s official website, the event is a celebration of life with proceeds going towards charities and non-profit organizations within the area.

“Water Lantern Festival brings together individuals from all ages, backgrounds, and walks of life to join in one emotional and memorable night. At the Water Lantern Festival, we cherish these moments and will do our best to help you have a memorable experience that you’ll never forget as you witness the beauty of thousands of lanterns reflecting upon the water,” the website states.

The festival takes place throughout multiple cities around the world, with the Canadian cities of Quebec, Regina, Vancouver, Hamilton, Calgary, Ottawa, Mississauga, and, of course, Montreal taking part.

For the Calgary event, a date has been confirmed and tickets are already rolling out. Montreal shan’t be far behind, and you can click the Notify Me tab on the event’s site to be kept in the loop.

Expect an evening filled with food trucks, music, lantern designing and finally, a magical launch of the lanterns into the water as the sun goes down.

For our pals over in Calgary, their event includes a floating lantern, a commemorative drawstring bag, a marker, and a wristband. Expect something similar, if not the same, when more details float through about Montreal’s event.

Continue Reading

Anglais

Euthanasia order on hold for Montreal dog that attacked children

admin

Published

on

By

A pit bull dog that attacked four children and two adults in August 2018 in Montreal North will not be euthanized in the immediate future.

The euthanasia order has been temporarily suspended pending the appeal of a Quebec Superior Court decision.

On Tuesday, Judge Lukasz Granosik rejected a request to halt the euthanasia order issued by the Montreal North borough, which declared the animal a “dangerous dog.”

The City of Montreal has not changed its mind. This is only a delay before it proceeds with euthanizing the dog, a source told the Canadian Press.

Shotta, the one-year-old dog, was in the care of its owner’s acquaintance in August 2018. The dog attacked four children and two adults, causing serious injuries in separate incidents on the same day.

After the attacks, the dog was taken from the home and entrusted to the SPCA.

WATCH: Dog found dead in Angrignon Park

The Road to Home Rescue Support, an American shelter, asked the court if it could take in the dog. Christa Frineau, the dog’s owner, had also asked that Shotta not be euthanized.

Granosik refused to grant the request.

—With files from Global’s Kalina Laframboise

Continue Reading

Anglais

9 Things To Do In Montreal This Friday, Saturday & Sunday

admin

Published

on

By

Today’s sunny skies have me itching to make weekend plans. I absolutely cannot wait to make the most of this warmer weather. This might be the time to inflate my bike tires and dust off my running shoes…

Whether you want to brush up on your cooking skills, let loose, or fill your stomach with amazing food, there’s an event out there for you. Read on for 9 fun things you can do with friends or a fling this weekend.

TL;DR Read on for 9 fun things you can do in Montreal this weekend.

Let Yourself Go At Dress Up

Where: 185 Avenue Van Horne, Montréal.

When: Friday, March 29, 9:00 p.m.

Continue Reading

Chat

Actualités2 semaines ago

Recensement: Statistique Canada révise sa question sur l’origine ethnique

Actualités2 semaines ago

Pénurie d’infirmières: le gouvernement dévoile sa stratégie

Actualités2 semaines ago

Commerce.Au Canada, les vins des colonies israéliennes ne peuvent plus porter la mention “Produit d’Israël”

Actualités2 semaines ago

Le Bloc québécois, plus nécessaire que jamais

Uncategorized2 semaines ago

Les clients de Desjardins, pas les bienvenus partout

Actualités2 semaines ago

« Ce climat de violence est inacceptable » : les députés LRM inquiets après de nouvelles dégradations de permanences

Actualités2 semaines ago

Hyundai enquêtera sur l’explosion d’une Kona EV électrique à Montréal

Actualités2 semaines ago

Statistique Canada revoit sa question sur l’origine ethnique dans le recensement

Actualités2 semaines ago

Quelles mesures du Ceta sont mauvaises pour l’environnement ?

Actualités2 semaines ago

Déjà une demande d’action collective déposée contre Capital One au Québec

Actualités2 semaines ago

Le quart des Albertains prêts à quitter le pays

Actualités2 semaines ago

Le Canada devra intégrer le concept de finance durable pour assurer sa croissance

Arts Et Spectacles1 mois ago

Des croupiers de casinos de Vancouver congédiés pour tricherie et complot

Actualités2 mois ago

Table ronde d’actualité internationale Royaume-(dés)Uni cherche nouveau leader

Actualités2 mois ago

Economie.Libra, nouvelle monnaie virtuelle et bras armé de Facebook

Actualités2 mois ago

Vers un capitalisme vert ? De très gros investisseurs internationaux dénoncent plus de 700 grandes entreprises, dont 39 françaises, pour défaut de politiques environnementales

Actualités2 mois ago

Les États-Unis publient de nouvelles photos contre l’Iran et déploient 1000 soldats dans la région

Actualités2 mois ago

Magnifique Society 2019 : un festival rémois aux ambitions internationales

Actualités2 mois ago

La France dénonce «l’annexion» de la Crimée par la Russie, Moscou lui rappelle le cas de Mayotte

Actualités2 mois ago

Simon Laplace : «les Français éprouvent une certaine tendresse pour Jacques Chirac»

Anglais9 mois ago

Body found after downtown Lethbridge apartment building fire, police investigating – Lethbridge

Styles De Vie10 mois ago

Salon du chocolat 2018: les 5 temps forts

Anglais8 mois ago

27 CP Rail cars derail near Lake Louise, Alta.

Anglais7 mois ago

Man facing eviction from family home on Toronto Islands gets reprieve — for now

Santé Et Nutrition10 mois ago

Gluten-Free Muffins

Santé Et Nutrition8 mois ago

We Try Kin Euphorics and How to REALLY Get the Glow | Healthyish

Anglais7 mois ago

This B.C. woman’s recipe is one of the most popular of all time — and the story behind it is bananas

Anglais6 mois ago

A photo taken on Toronto’s Corso Italia 49 years ago became a family legend. No one saw it — until now

Styles De Vie11 mois ago

Renaud Capuçon, rédacteur en chef du Figaroscope

Mode7 mois ago

Paris : chez Cécile Roederer co-fondatrice de Smallable

Anglais9 mois ago

Ontario Tories argue Trudeau’s carbon plan is ‘unconstitutional’

Anglais9 mois ago

Trudeau government would reject Jason Kenney, taxpayers group in carbon tax court fight

Anglais11 mois ago

Condo developer Thomas Liu — who collected millions but hasn’t built anything — loses court fight with Town of Ajax

Anglais6 mois ago

This couple shares a 335-square-foot micro condo on Queen St. — and loves it

Anglais9 mois ago

100 years later, Montreal’s Black Watch regiment returns to Wallers, France

Anglais7 mois ago

Province’s push for private funding, additional stops puts Scarborough subway at risk of delays

Technologie6 mois ago

YouTube recommande de la pornographie juvénile, allègue un internaute

Styles De Vie7 mois ago

Ford Ranger Raptor, le pick-up roule des mécaniques

Styles De Vie7 mois ago

quel avenir pour le Carré des Horlogers?

Mode10 mois ago

Kid’s collections : Little Hedonist

Trending