Judge blasts province’s ‘unconscionable’ inaction on cramped Brampton courthouse, leading to ‘unacceptable’ hearing delays


A senior judge blasted the provincial government Monday for failing to provide sufficient courtroom space in Brampton, which is leading to “very real and unacceptable delays” in the hearing of cases at one of the busiest courthouses in the country.

“The Ontario government — past and present — is either wilfully blind to the erosion of trust caused by its failure to take timely steps to address the facilities crisis in Brampton, or it believes that spending on this courthouse will not result in more votes,” Regional Senior Justice Peter Daley of the Superior Court of Justice said in court.

Regional Senior Justice Peter Daley of the Superior Court of Justice, speaking in court about the lack of space at the Brampton courthouse on Monday.
Regional Senior Justice Peter Daley of the Superior Court of Justice, speaking in court about the lack of space at the Brampton courthouse on Monday.  (Andrew Francis Wallace / Toronto Star)

“Either way, the government’s inaction is unconscionable and inconsistent with its obligations to the public in Peel region.”

The Superior Court hears all civil cases, some family matters and the most serious criminal cases including murder. The lack of space in Brampton — located in one of the fastest-growing regions of the country — has meant that cases have had to be transferred to other municipalities including Milton, Kitchener and Toronto, leading to added delay and extra costs for litigants, Daley said.

“Transferring Brampton cases to other centres has a very real impact on the people who live and work in Peel region,” Daley said. “We have received letters of complaints from lawyers, members of the public and families of litigants who have been unable to attend these other court locations outside of Peel region by public transit, creating real access to justice obstacles.”

As of Nov. 1, the earliest date the court can offer to hear most motions in civil and family matters is eight months down the road, and 16 months for trials lasting more than five days, Daley said. For criminal matters, whether a short or long trial, the earliest date is 10 months from now.

Read more:

Judge rules mom can collect $15,000 in legal costs one day after Star writes about nearly two-year delay

‘It’s actually shocking how archaic’ Ontario’s criminal courts are

New Toronto courthouse will increase risk of gang violence downtown: secret police report

Courts have come under heightened scrutiny to deal with criminal cases in a timely fashion since the 2016 Supreme Court of Canada decision in R v. Jordan set strict timelines to complete such cases before they must be tossed for violating an accused person’s constitutional right to a trial in a reasonable time.

In Superior Court, the time limit is 30 months between a person’s arrest and the anticipated conclusion of their trial. Daley said the court has had to reprioritize cases that would otherwise be at risk of being tossed.

Rarely have judges spoken so forcefully in public on challenges facing their court, but as Daley pointed out, the Superior Court had “engaged all the appropriate channels within the Ministry of the Attorney General to seek timely solutions to the pressing space demands,” but with little success.

(Daley also noted he had invited Attorney General Caroline Mulroney to send a representative to hear his remarks in court Monday, but the invitation was declined.)

In an unusual move, the judge even allowed cameras inside the courtroom to record his remarks prior to the start of the day’s proceedings, “in view of the broad public interest at stake in these issues.” He made clear he was only addressing problems facing the Superior Court and not the Ontario Court of Justice, the lower level of court that hears most criminal cases and also occupies space at the Brampton courthouse.

Construction at the Brampton courthouse on Monday.
Construction at the Brampton courthouse on Monday.  (Andrew Francis Wallace/Toronto Star)

Compounding the spacing issue is the fact that a new six-floor addition under construction adjacent to the existing courthouse will be mostly empty once it’s completed. Daley said government would only be “fitting out” the basement and first two floors, leaving the remaining four floors a “vacant shell.”

Those first few floors were expected to be completed by now, but will only open around July 2019, Daley said. Even then, he said, no courtrooms will be completed, but only a few “retiring rooms” that could be temporarily used as judges’ chambers.

The judge urged government to approve funding for filling out the remaining four floors as soon as possible.

“It has become clearly evident to all … that the idea of only partially completing the courthouse addition is folly at its highest,” Daley said. “Not only does it not make any economic or practical sense to delay the completion of the remaining floors — this is simply further evidence of the provincial government’s continuing breach of its statutory and constitutional duty to provide appropriate courthouse facilities to this court.”

Daley’s comments were welcomed by legal organizations, who agreed the lack of space is causing serious access to justice issues.

“The long-standing practice of sending cases out of jurisdiction has created a number of obstacles for clients who must bear the costs associated with additional travel expenses and legal fees,” said Daniel Brown, a vice-president of the Criminal Lawyers’ Association. “This practice has also made it more challenging for both the Crown and defence to ensure important witnesses attend trial.”

Jacques Gallant is a Toronto-based reporter covering legal affairs. Follow him on Twitter: @JacquesGallant


Source link

قالب وردپرس

Federal minister blasts Ontario Tories over cuts to francophone services


A federal Liberal cabinet minister is blasting the Ontario government’s decision to eliminate spending on francophone initiatives from the province’s budget.

In a letter that was sent Friday and obtained by the Star, Official Languages Minister Mélanie Joly expressed what she described as her “sincere disappointment” at the provincial Progressive Conservatives’ move to eliminate the office of the French language services commissioner and to scrap plans for a French-language university.

Mélanie Joly, federal minister of official languages and La Francophonie, described the Ontario government’s budget cuts as “devastating decisions that will have a lasting impact on the more than 600,000 Franco-Ontarians and the more than 7.9 million francophones across Canada.”
Mélanie Joly, federal minister of official languages and La Francophonie, described the Ontario government’s budget cuts as “devastating decisions that will have a lasting impact on the more than 600,000 Franco-Ontarians and the more than 7.9 million francophones across Canada.”  (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS FILE PHOTO)

Premier Doug Ford’s government revealed the cuts Thursday in its fall economic update. The Tories said they were necessary in order to reduce costs and address what the party says is a $15-billion deficit left behind by the previous Liberal government.

“These are devastating decisions that will have a lasting impact on the more than 600,000 Franco-Ontarians and the more than 7.9 million francophones across Canada,” Joly wrote in the letter addressed to Caroline Mulroney, Ontario’s minister responsible for francophone affairs.

Joly said the promotion of the French language is “central to our common approach of supporting our two official languages and defending the rights of minorities in Canada,” and warned that eliminating the commissioner’s position and abandoning plans for the university “will have severe consequences on the vitality of the Franco-Ontario community and the Canadian Francophonie.”

Joly requested a meeting with Mulroney “as soon as possible” to discuss the issue.

The previous Ontario Liberal government created the office of the French language commissioner in 2007. Its mandate is to ensure the rights of citizens and obligations of the government are respected according to the French Language Services Act. François Boileau has held the position since its inception. In the fiscal year of 2017-18, his office fielded 315 complaints or requests for information.

The Tories didn’t immediately say how much the province will save by closing the office, but in prior years its annual budget was about $1.2 million.

In 2017, a planning board also convened under the Ontario Liberals recommended the creation of a new French-language university in Toronto, at an estimated initial cost of $83.5 million that would be split equally between the provincial and federal governments.

In the run-up to the Ontario election in June, Ford’s PC party committed to following through with establishing the school.

The Tories argue that the elimination of the French language commissioner won’t result in a reduction of services because the position’s duties will be rolled into the office of the provincial ombudsman.

“The work that the commission did will continue; linguistic rights will be protected. Ontarians will continue to have an independent government office to come to make complaints if they have any,” Mulroney told Radio-Canada in an interview conducted in French on Friday.

“There will be an independent agent — the ombudsman — who is like the commissioner currently, who will study these complaints and produce reports if they wish.”

In a Facebook post, Mulroney’s parliamentary assistant Amanda Simard, the MPP for Glengarry-Prescott-Russell, acknowledged Franco-Ontarians were “concerned” about the loss of the commissioner. But she stressed that the office’s functions will “remain independent under the governance of the ombudsman.”

The Progressive Conservatives’ decision to cut spending on francophone initiatives made few headlines in the mainstream Ontario press this week, but drew sharp criticism in Quebec, where the move was seen by many as an attack on minority language rights.

Quebec Premier François Legault has pledged to raise the issue with Ford when the pair meet at Queen’s Park on Monday.

With more than 622,000 francophones in the province, Ontario is home to the largest such population in Canada outside of Quebec. Francophones make up roughly 4.7 per cent of the province’s population, according to the commissioner’s office.

Ben Spurr is a Toronto-based reporter. Reach him by email at bspurr@thestar.ca or follow him on Twitter: @BenSpurr


Source link

قالب وردپرس